M. Markley Antiques HOME

Gothic Cabinet with Intricate Tracery 4190


gothic cabinet tracery
Item 4190 Width 36, Height 39, Depth 16½ (in inches)
Wood - Oak
Date - Circa 1870
Country of Origin - France
Additional photos below text

This small cabinet, made of oak in a simple six-sided design, is a masterpiece of flamboyant Gothic decoration displaying a rare combination of intricacy of design with open tracery or >fenestrage.

In our business, we see cabinets of all shapes and sizes but rarely one that evokes such appreciation for High Gothic architecture and its influence on 19th century craftsmen such as Camille ALBERT, to whom this piece is attributed.

Albert was active in the late 19th century as architect of the city of Fécamp, a port in Normandy known for cod-fishing and for distilling Bénédictine Liqueur after the long-lost 16th century recipe for the elixir was rediscovered in 1863. The Palais Bénédictine was designed and built by Albert in a combination of Neo-Gothic and Neo-Renaissance styles for the owner of the distillery, Alexander-Prosper LeGrand. Still used for production, the Palais also includes a museum of art works from the 14th to the 16th centuries. This cabinet, along with a table and chairs, were all acquired by us in Fécamp.

All of the pieces, including this Cabinet 4190, appear to be made from the same oak, perhaps the same tree. We speculate that the furniture was crafted from trees felled during one of the hurricanes sweeping across northwestern France and the British Isles, such as the Great Storm of 1850. From contemporary accounts, we know that landowners often kept the felled trees to dry out and to be used for furniture and homes, replacing what was ruined in the storms and as an early form of recycling.

Examining the cabinet, we find the oak to be uncommonly dense with little grain visible, signaling that the oak trees must have been ancient and a part of the landscape for centuries. There are a number of knots and other anomalies that would have been shunned by the typical 19th century artisan as too challenging to work with. Here they are embraced, leading us to believe that the oak from which this furniture emerged had a special place in the hearts of its owner and maker. Perhaps after centuries in a pasture shading the cows responsible for Normandy's memorable butters and creams, the fallen tree lived on with its family at the center of meals and celebrations as a treasured set of dining room furniture and a reminder of the power of nature, despite man's efforts to tame it.

While exuberant in decoration, it is by no means overdone. Similarly, the absence of linen-fold panels on the sides — nice decoration but often a cliché and a simpler way to fill space — are notable for their absence.

We cannot overemphasize how intricate and fine the carving is on this piece, taking the basics of the Gothic vocabulary of arches, rosettes, lancets, soufflets and quatrefoils to the nth degree of beauty and refinement.

The front of the cabinet is comprised of two doors, each of which closes with its own latch. The left door is wider owing to the central lancets, which divide the front visually, being part of that door. Each door's design consists of a pointed arch divided into two sub-arches, which are each filled by two open lancet arches.

Above the main arch of each door panel is a large circular carving resembling a cathedral's rose window in intricacy of detail, again in an openwork treatment. In accordance with medieval tradition that no two things could be identical because only God was capable of such perfection, the two circular designs are quite distinct. In their richness of detail, they represent the most intricate carving we have ever encountered on a piece of furniture. We cannot even begin to imagine what tools were used to accomplish it and how long it must have taken.

Separating the front from the side panels and the side panels from one another, as well as from the back panel, are tall pilasters topped by finials. Below the top, and crowning each of the finials, is a frieze based on rounded, crocketed arches and clustered balls, possibly grapes.

The side panels, both those perpendicular to the front and those at an angle, incorporate more tracery motifs of flowers inside soufflets and shapes reminiscent of the boteh found in Persian rugs, all punctuated with bits of vegetation or crockets, possibly stylized grape leaves. Again, each side panel is different from all the others.

The top of this cabinet brings us to a mystery and possibly a unifying theme for this piece along with the table and chairs acquired with it — the wood. The top is characterized by dark, dense oak with splits and large knots in it. These are not defects of recent origin but rather part and parcel of the cabinet dating back to when it was made.

Why make such a magnificently carved cabinet out of wood with knots — something a furniture maker would discard or use for backs and drawers? The answer, we think, lies with a special tree. Given that we acquired all these pieces in a city in northern France, an area prone to cyclonic windstorms swooping off the Atlantic, our speculation is that the pieces were commissioned from a treasured oak tree felled in one of these massive blows and preserved by its owners, for all time, in this magnificent furniture.


Ader-Tajan, Collection Bruno Perrier Haute Epoque (Catalog for Sale at Auction on April 6, 1992 at the Hôtel Drouot, Paris); Boccador, Jacqueline, Le Mobilier Français du Moyen Age à la Renaissance (Editions d'Art Monelle Hayot, Saint-Just-en-Chaussée, 1988); Thirion, Jacques, Le Mobilier du Moyen Age et de la Renaissance en France (Editions Faton, Dijon, 1998); Viollet-le-Duc, Eugène, Le Mobilier Médiéval (Georges Bernage, editor) (Editions Heimdal, 2003)


Being rather narrow in depth, this cabinet is ideal for an entryway or foyer in a home or as a decorative item in an office.

4190-open tracery
4190-open tracery pattern
4190-detail of circular tracery pattern
4190-gothic rose window pattern
4190-carved tracery at side
4190-finial and top
4190-circular tracery pattern on side
4190-side view of gothic cabinet
4190-lancet arches
4190-top of oak cabinet from normandy
4190-interior gothic cabinet open tracery